Abstract Share valuations are known to adjust to new information entering the market, such as regulatory disclosures. We study whether the language of such news items can improve short-term and especially long-term (24 months) forecasts of stock indices. For this purpose, this work utilizes predictive models suited to high-dimensional data and specifically compares techniques for data-driven and knowledge-driven dimensionality reduction in order to avoid overfitting. Our experiments, based on 75,927 ad hoc announcements from 1996–2016, reveal the following results: in the long run, text-based models succeed in reducing forecast errors below baseline predictions from historic lags at a statistically significant level. Our research provides implications to business applications of decision-support in financial markets, especially given the growing prevalence of index ETFs (exchange traded funds).