Forbidden Natural Law: The Return of Values Positivism Tried to Kill An urgent exploration of the widening chasm between technical legality and human justice. In an era where legal systems are increasingly efficient in their procedural precision, something essential has been quietly lost. Forbidden Natural Law examines the growing tension between legal systems that function with impeccable technical validity and the failure of those same systems to sustain moral legitimacy, human meaning, and a connection to reality. The author introduces the concept of "Normative Orphanhood"—a condition in which a rule can be perfectly valid according to the code, yet catastrophic in its meaning for the individual living under it. What You Will Find Inside Using the recurring metaphor of a forgotten coat in a tailor shop—an unclosed question without a deadline—the book illustrates how certain obligations persist even when there is no statute to cite and no court to enforce them. The work expands this reflection into the most critical challenges of our time, including: * The Crisis of Evidence: How generative artificial intelligence and synthetic media are separating "fact" from witnessed events, challenging the law's ability to discern truth in an age of algorithmic fabrication. * Algorithmic Manipulation: An analysis of how technology models and exploits human behavior to manufacture desire, rendering traditional doctrines of consent increasingly obsolete. * The Intergenerational Debt: The urgency of climate law, which forces us to recognize obligations to future generations—people who do not yet exist, but whose capacity for a livable life depends on choices being made today. * The Return of Natural Law: A modern recovery of Natural Law that relies not on archaic dogma, but on the honest, durable insistence that some debts are owed prior to enactment, prior to consent, and prior to the presence of a claimant in the room. Why This Book Is Necessary Now Forbidden Natural Law does not seek to discard legal positivism, but rather questions whether it can, on its own, sustain a society that demands more than blind obedience to procedural rules. It is essential reading for jurists, administrators, policymakers, and anyone who has ever questioned why a "correct" system can produce results that are profoundly wrong. This work proposes that Law should be more than a mechanism of coordination; it must be a commitment to human dignity that endures—even when no one is watching and even when the system itself has forgotten its original purpose. * Natural Law – The central theme of the book, which seeks to recover a modern understanding of natural law obligations. * Legal Philosophy – The overarching field the book engages with, questioning the foundations of modern legal systems. * Legal Positivism – A major school of thought the author critiques, particularly regarding its focus on procedural validity over moral legitimacy. * Artificial Intelligence Law – A core topic of the book, specifically addressing how AI challenges evidence, authentication, and legal fact-finding. * Jurisprudence – The book provides a critical re-examination of jurisprudential theories and their practical application. * Climate Law – The subject of the final chapter, exploring the intergenerational obligations created by climate change. * Legal Ethics – The book addresses these issues by discussing the gap between what is legally "valid" and what remains morally "owed". Natural Law, Legal Positivism, Jurisprudence, Normative Orphanhood, Legal Theory, Philosophy of Law, Legal Ethics, Artificial Intelligence, AI, Algorithmic Governance, Digital Evidence, Synthetic Media, Generative AI, Technology Regulation, Digital Ethics, Machine Learning in Law, Predictive Justice, Deepfakes, Automated Decision-Making, Data Privacy, Legal Technology, Tech Policy, Climate Law, Intergenerational Justice, Environmental Law, Climate Change, Entropy, Future Generations, Sustainability, Global Governance, Thermodynamics in Law, Legal Institutions, Social Contract, Institutional Design, Sociology of Law, Human Agency, Moral Philosophy, Legal Legitimacy, Facticity, Legal Validity, Rule of Law, Evidence Law, Contract Law, Procedural Law, Property Law, Inheritance, Obligation, Duty, Moral Remainder, Legal Reform, Evidentiary Standards, Adjudication, Judicial Discretion, Human Condition, Mortality, Fragility, Time, Memory, Narrative, Inherited Obligations, Meta-ethics, Legal History, Comparative Law, Legal Hermeneutics, Human-Centric AI, Normative Failure, Fairness, Justice, Responsibility, Accountability
Paper
The full text of this publication is not hosted on 44B due to licensing.
Read it at OpenAlex